Mystery Straps

Choose your size and tier, and we'll select a mystery watch strap from our discontinued and overstock inventory. Higher tiers include straps with higher original retail values. All straps are new and unused. Mystery straps are final sale.

Not sure what fits your watch? Use our Strap Finder to find the correct width and compatible straps by watch brand and model.
14 products
Mystery Strap Leather - Holben's
Mystery Strap Leather - Value
Retail $30–$40
$15
Mystery Strap Leather - Holben's
Mystery Strap Leather - Standard
Retail $40–$70
$24
Mystery Strap Leather - Holben's
Mystery Strap Leather - Premium
Retail $70–$115
$39
Mystery Strap Leather - Holben's
Mystery Strap Leather - High End
Retail $115–$165
$79
Mystery Strap Leather - Holben's
Mystery Strap Leather - Ultra
Retail $198+
$119
Mystery Strap Rubber - Holben's
Mystery Strap Rubber - Standard
Retail $40–$70
$24
Mystery Strap Rubber - Holben's
Mystery Strap Rubber - High End
Retail $115–$165
$79
Mystery Strap Sailcloth - Holben's
Mystery Strap Sailcloth - Premium
Retail $70–$115
$39
Mystery Strap Sailcloth - Holben's
Mystery Strap Sailcloth - Ultra
Retail $198+
$119
Mystery Strap Artem Loop-Less - Holben's
Mystery Strap Sailcloth - Artem Loop-Less
Retail $133+
$99
Mystery Strap Perlon - Value - Holben's
Mystery Strap Perlon
Retail $32–$34
$15
Mystery Strap Vegan - Holben's
Mystery Strap Vegan
Retail $30–$40
$15
Mystery Strap Erika's Originals - Holben's
Mystery Strap Erika's Originals
Retail $110–$132
$69
Mystery Strap Erika's Originals Fixed Lugs - Holben's
Mystery Strap Erika's Originals - Fixed Lugs
Retail $110–$132
From $69